StubbornFacts
Stubborn Facts
Stubborn Facts

Navigation

User login

Subscribe via RSS

Resources

The latest from our partner, the PoliGazette

Blog Roll

Glass Houses

Submitted by Jason Steck on Fri, 09/21/2007 - 12:51pm

TMV columnist Shaun Mullen contends that the refusal of GOP candidates to participate in a debate sponsored by Univision is proof positive that the Republican Party base is irredeemably racist. Trouble is, as even the Democrats at A Pedestrian View note with displeasure, the post traffics in more racist stereotypes than he is able to quote from Republicans. In his drive to assert that (almost) all Republicans are racists (they presumably kick their dogs and beat their grandmothers too), Mullen's post invokes crude stereotypes about black language skills, vaudeville, and even that old standby, fried chicken.

Criticizing the Republican party for its embrace of an anti-immigration position that is self-destructive and self-defeating is, of course, valid. But trying to leverage that into a broader claim that (almost) all Republicans are racist is overreaching, dishonest, and offensive. Doing so by using racist stereotypes is the classic case of throwing stones while living in glass houses.

Besides, until partisans equally criticize Democrats who refuse to debate at FoxNews, they are just being, well, partisans.

Both sides are wimps, GOP will likely lose more

OK, I'll criticise both sides. I think it's a good chance to show courage, and that's what this job is about. Candidates wbo beard the lion like that DO tend to come out ahead from impressing people who otherwise wouln't've paid attention. Certainly, if I were in any shoes other than Hillary's I WOULD, to get some momentum going.

I think the GOP is losing more than the Dems, though. The Latinos were an important part of the last (R) win, and I seem to remember the win was pretty darned close, and now it'll take extra work to get more than a handful of votes atall, despite Latino cultural conservatism. By contrast, Clinton got his win without performing on Fox. And, like Clinton, Hillary will play well outside the blue states already because she is who she is, if she runs a similarly smart campaign.

Bwahaha!

Asians

The odd assumption is that racism is a one-way street. Blacks are consistently the most reliable group in terms of % voting for Democrats. If any group is loyal to a party on the basis of race, that's the direction it's going. The politics of race are concentrated on the left, so that the arrows come form that side is not a surprise. Conservatives are, to a greater degree, a party of values (not just moral values, but a party that sets its framework around principles rather than a patchwork of special interest groups). This may explain why a majority of Asian-Americans vote for Republicans in spite of the racism allegedly concentrated in that party. Or are Asians being racist in their vote while blacks are not? Are the unions (not exactly a conservative group) trying to block immigration because they're racist or, because, as they consistently state, they're economic protectionists? They don't care what race the immigrants are, they want limits. This is the same logic (lack thereof) underlying the GOP base.

Recent comments

Advertisements
StubbornFacts.us does not endorse the content of any advertisement

Featured Movie

Syndicate

Syndicate content

Who's online

There are currently 2 users and 7 guests online.

Online users

  • Tyler359
  • bucyrus