StubbornFacts
Stubborn Facts
Stubborn Facts

Navigation

User login

Subscribe via RSS

Resources

The latest from our partner, the PoliGazette

Blog Roll

Oh, dear, we've gone and ignored diplomatic protocol...

Submitted by Pat on Fri, 01/12/2007 - 8:00am

Oh, dear! We've upset the Iranians and the Russians by seizing several Iranians at an Iranian "consulate" in northern Iraq. Iran is blustering about the "U.S. illegal move". Iran also issued a "strong condemnation of the US forces' action which was against all international regulations." The Russians said that this was the "the crudest possible violation of the Vienna convention on consular relations."

Well, no. The "crudest possible violation of the Vienna convention on consular relations" would be to take 53 diplomats of an embassy and hold them as hostages for 444 days, often in brutal conditions and subject to hostile interrogations.

It really takes an exceptional amount of gall for Iran to complain to us about the sanctity of embassies. I guess we should have let "students" make the raid.

For the record, Iraq says that the facility had not yet been granted consular status. U.S. forces released two Iranians with diplomatic passports almost immediately after the raid.

Irony

Ironically, the word that best describes the Iranian reaction is a Yiddish one: hutzpah.

So true, David. I was

So true, David. I was thinking the same thing.

And if they could just get folks to buy it, I have this bizarre vision of Iran and Syria issuing a few hundred thousand sets of embassy credentials to heavily armed "diplomats."

Thought the cold war was over? The attack on the US Embassy in Greece is being claimed by a Marxist group. Love that timing, right about the time Russia was issuing their condemnation.

Iran and an embassy

Pat;
That was my first thought also. Still, I'm puzzled by the Kurds being so p.o.'d

"Still, I'm puzzled by the

"Still, I'm puzzled by the Kurds being so p.o.'d"

Well, Chris, I guess you share this feeling with some in the US intelligence community and the Pentagon, especially those who planned and apporved this operation. After all, taking the intents and goals of other parties into account has never been a characteristic of the average american. But, really, nobody with a bit of emphatical thinking left should be surprised that the Kurds didn't like that raid on their own soil at all.

So far, they have successfully stayed out of the sectarian struggle, which is very important for them, since they are a small minority in Iraq and they already face a mighty adversayry at their north-western border. Along come some cowboy yankees and hijack those Iranian guys, who wouldn't have been able to stay in Erbil without the approval of Kurd leaders in the first place. This doesn't only put Kurdish hospitality in a very bad light, it raises suspicions that this actually was an intrigue they conducted together with the US.

Since Iran has a strong influence on Iraq's shiites, this will sure lead to tensions with the Shiite. But that's the party the Kurds, who will have to defend Kirkuk against Sunnis in the case of civil war, don't want to have as an enemy. Of course they are pissed off, what the hell were you thinking?

tough neighbourhood

There is a Lebanese saying that the Kurds apparently keep in mind; "Your neighbour is closer than your far away cousin".

The Kurds have to keep in mind their position straddling 4 borders; Iraq, Iran, Syrian and Turkey... There are even a few in Azerbaijan. This is a double-edged sword, which also allow the Kurds to "project" some influence across those borders.

With this in mind, I agree that the Kurds most likely coordinated with the US, since the Iranians in this Irbil where far out of Persia's domain. But they could not "officially" approve of the action, since they still need to keep bridges open. Coming on the heels of some moves around Sadr City, and the recent bombings in Arabstan, this was a clear message for the Persians not to stray too far from their sandbox.

The message reinforces an earlier verbal warning by the Kurdish president. But I do not think the Persians got the message yet.

Not particularly

Who says that the Kurds are that ticked off? According to this report, Kurdish security forces took control of the building after U.S. forces left. Yes, their formal statement condemns the action, but as diplomatic statements go, that one's pretty mild, frankly. Most of the Kurdish statements have emphasized that the U.S. did not give the Kurdish Regional Government advance notice of the raid. That suggests to me that, like most countries around the world, they are happy to blame the U.S. for doing things that they really wanted to happen, but don't want to suffer the consequences for.

Here, the Kurds did ask the Iranians to open this "consulate" (which wasn't officially a consulate yet) to improve some cross-border paperwork hassles. They could hardly support a raid even if the Iranians were using it as a base for assisting anti-American operations. The Kurds are also very sensitive generally about their autonomy. There are strong forces in favor of the declaration of a "Kurdistan", something which just won't happen because of Turkish opposition, so they're sensitive to proper protocols being followed for prior notice of such things.

Contrary to your extraordinarily pessimistic tone, however, that doesn't make this that big a deal to the Kurds. They also don't want their area to become a haven for anti-American operations by Iranian-supported forces. The Kurds actually generally like and support America, and definitely supported the removal of Saddam Hussein from power. They mostly get mad at us when we abandon them, as we have several times over the past few decades, in order to practice some nice realpolitik, which usually involves us looking the other way while our adversaries wreak havoc on innocent people so long as they give us what we want, like keeping the flow of oil going.

P.S. We frown on vulgarity here and work hard to promote a civil tone of debate, so in the future, please refrain from using phrases like "what the hell were you thinking".

Recent comments

Advertisements
StubbornFacts.us does not endorse the content of any advertisement

Featured Movie

Syndicate

Syndicate content

Who's online

There are currently 1 user and 7 guests online.

Online users

  • bucyrus